Is Your Business Ready for a Pen Test? A CIO’s Guide to Getting It Right

Penetration testing (or pen testing) isn’t just a box to check—it’s one of the best ways to uncover vulnerabilities before bad actors do. Whether you’re testing for compliance, strengthening security, or just making sure your defenses are solid, a pen test can offer invaluable insights into your environment’s weaknesses and help prioritize your security investments.

But here’s the thing: if you’re not prepared, you might not get the results you need. Poor scoping, missing approvals, or IT teams inadvertently shutting down the test can lead to inconclusive results or, worse, disruptions that damage trust in the process. Before you bring in the ethical hackers, make sure your organization is truly ready. This readiness checklist, tailored for CIOs and CTOs, helps ensure your next pen test delivers real value.

---

1. Set Clear Goals and Define Scope

Not all pen tests are the same, so you need to define what success looks like.

• What are you testing? Are you looking at networks, web apps, cloud environments, or all of the above?
• What type of test do you need? Black Box (external hacker simulation), Grey Box (limited access), or White Box (full transparency)?
• What’s the business objective? Compliance (PCI-DSS, HIPAA, etc.), internal security audit, or general security assessment?
• What’s off-limits? Some systems may be too critical to test live—define what’s in scope and what isn’t.

Why it matters: A clear scope helps avoid unnecessary disruptions and ensures testers focus on your biggest risks.

---

2. Get the Right Approvals in Place

Pen testing without proper approval? Bad idea.

• Executive buy-in – Make sure leadership understands the why and how of the test.
• Legal and compliance checks – Ensure testing aligns with industry regulations and company policies.
• Rules of Engagement (RoE) – Set expectations for testing hours, escalation protocols, and any no-go zones.

Why it matters: You don’t want security teams mistaking the test for a real attack or leadership getting blindsided by unexpected downtime.

---

3. Prep Your IT and Security Teams

Nobody likes surprises—especially your IT and security teams.

• Tell your IT team in advance so they don’t accidentally block the testers.
• Check your security monitoring tools to ensure they’re logging activity correctly.
• Decide how to handle alerts – Will your security team treat them as real threats or let them play out?
• Disable automated blocking (if necessary) to allow testers to fully assess vulnerabilities.

Why it matters: A pen test should simulate a real attack, but you don’t want it shut down before you get useful data.

---

4. Backup Everything (Just in Case)

Pen tests shouldn’t cause outages—but things happen.

• Ensure full backups of critical systems and databases.
• Have rollback procedures in place in case something breaks.
• Double-check business continuity plans in case of unexpected disruptions.

Why it matters: You don’t want a security test to accidentally take down a key system with no easy way to restore it.

---

5. Prepare for Social Engineering Attacks

Many pen tests include phishing attempts—are your employees ready?

• Train employees to recognize phishing and suspicious activity.
• Test your team’s response to fake emails or phone calls.
• Limit user privileges to minimize potential damage if credentials get compromised.

Why it matters: Your security is only as strong as your weakest link, and often, that’s human error.

---

6. Check In with Vendors and Third-Party Services

Pen testing a cloud app or a vendor-managed system? Get their approval first.

• Notify any third-party vendors if their systems will be tested.
• Check cloud provider policies (AWS, Azure, etc.)—some require advance notice.
• Confirm external services allow security testing to avoid violations of terms of service.

Why it matters: You don’t want a cloud provider shutting down your account because they think you’re launching an attack.

---

7. Plan for the Post-Test Phase

The test is just the beginning—what you do after matters most.

• Schedule a debrief meeting with the testers, IT, and leadership to review findings.
• Prioritize vulnerabilities based on severity and impact.
• Develop a remediation plan and set deadlines for fixes.
• Plan for follow-up testing to ensure issues are resolved.

Why it matters: Finding vulnerabilities is only useful if you actually fix them.

---

Final Thoughts

Penetration testing is an important part of a strong security strategy, but it’s only effective if you’re prepared. A well-planned test gives you the insights you need to strengthen defenses, improve response plans, and stay ahead of threats.

So, is your business ready? If you’re unsure, it might be worth running a pre-test security assessment before diving into a full pen test. The goal isn’t just to check a box—it’s to make sure your security holds up when it counts.

---

Need help planning or executing your next penetration test?
Dataprise can help you scope, prepare for, and act on penetration test results to truly strengthen your security posture. Contact us today to get started.